The person in this story is made up to explain the rules. The ruling is real.
A refund, a rejection and a long wait
Suresh runs a works contract business. In early 2023 he filed refund claims for the unused input tax credit that had piled up because his inputs were taxed at a higher rate than his output. The officer rejected the claims. Suresh did not give up. He appealed, and the appellate authority ruled in his favour.
He then filed new applications to actually get the money, and the department paid the refunds within two months. Suresh asked for interest on the long wait. The answer was no: “You were paid within 60 days of your new application, so no interest is due.”
Was that fair? In November 2026 a GST Appellate Tribunal bench in Andhra Pradesh said no. Here is what it decided and what it means for you.
The ruling at a glance
- Where: GST Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT), Andhra Pradesh State Bench, Vijayawada.
- Case: Appeal No. APL/1/VJY/2026, decided together with seven other appeals in one common order dated 11 November 2026. The refunds were claimed under the CGST and APGST Acts.
- The question: if a refund claim is first rejected, then allowed on appeal, does interest run from the first application, or only from the second application filed after the appeal?
- The answer: from the first application. The tribunal said the department cannot deny interest just because it paid within 60 days of the second application.
What happened, step by step
- The taxpayer filed eight refund applications for the inverted duty structure, for tax periods between December 2018 and March 2020. They were filed between 18 January 2023 and 29 March 2023.
- The original officer rejected them. The ground was that the taxpayer was not eligible for refund because of Notification No. 15/2017-Central Tax (Rate), which covers specified construction services.
- On 23 September 2023, the First Appellate Authority set aside the rejections and allowed the claims.
- On 25 and 26 September 2023, the taxpayer filed consequential applications, asking for the refunds and for interest from the day after 60 days from the original applications.
- The refunds were sanctioned in November 2023. The department refused the interest, because it had paid within 60 days of the consequential applications.
What Section 56 says
Section 56 of the CGST Act deals with interest on delayed refunds. In simple words:
- The main rule: if a refund ordered under section 54(5) is not paid within 60 days from the date the application was received, interest is payable for the delay beyond 60 days, until the date of refund. The rate is up to 6% a year, and it is notified at 6%.
- The proviso: if the refund arises from an order of an adjudicating authority, appellate authority, tribunal or court that has become final, and it is not paid within 60 days of the application filed because of that order, the rate is up to 9% a year, from the day after those 60 days.
- The Explanation: an order of refund passed by an appellate authority, tribunal or court is treated as an order passed under section 54(5).
The department’s argument and the tribunal’s answer
The department said the refunds were paid within 60 days of the consequential applications, so no interest was payable. It also said the main rule, the proviso and the Explanation work separately, and it relied on a Supreme Court judgment, Union of India v. Willowood Chemicals.
The tribunal disagreed:
- The second application is only a process step. It exists to get the money released after the appeal. It does not wipe out the interest that has already built up from the first application.
- The 9% rate does not cancel the 6% rate. The higher rate applies to the later period if the department is slow after the appeal. The ordinary 6% for the earlier period remains.
- Willowood was about the rate, not the start date. The tribunal said that case dealt with which rate applies, and it did not decide from when the interest starts.
- Rule 93 and a CBIC circular support this. The amount stays debited in your credit ledger while the appeal is pending, and after winning you file a fresh application only to obtain the refund allowed by the appellate order (CBIC Circular No. 111/30/2019-GST, dated 3 October 2019).
The tribunal also relied on earlier decisions that took the same view, including the Supreme Court in Ranbaxy Laboratories (under the Central Excise Act) and High Court decisions in Bansal International (Delhi), SBI Cards (Punjab and Haryana), Lupin and Altisource (Bombay) and Qualcomm India (Telangana).
What the tribunal ordered
- The appeals were allowed, and the department’s orders refusing interest were set aside.
- The taxpayer is entitled to interest at 6% a year on the qualifying refund amounts, from the day after 60 days from receipt of each original application, until the refund was actually paid.
- This is subject to checking that each original application was complete and had the required documents (section 54 read with Rule 89), and the other conditions.
- The officer must work out the interest separately for each of the eight claims and complete this within eight weeks.
A simple example
The numbers below are made up and simplified. Real interest depends on the exact dates and the rules that exclude some periods.
| Step | Detail |
|---|---|
| Original application received | 1 February 2023, complete with documents |
| 60 days end | 2 April 2023 |
| Interest starts | 3 April 2023 |
| Refund amount | ₹10,00,000 |
| Refund actually paid | 15 November 2023 |
| Days of delay | 227 days |
| Interest at 6% a year | ₹10,00,000 × 6% × 227 ÷ 365 = about ₹37,300 |
Under the department’s approach, Suresh would have received nothing for those 227 days.
How the interest is paid out
Under Rule 94, when interest is due, the officer issues an order with a payment order in Form GST RFD-05. The order states the delayed refund amount, the period of delay and the interest. The interest is credited to your bank account on record. Some periods are not counted. For example, time you take beyond 15 days to reply to a deficiency notice in Form GST RFD-08, or time lost because your bank details were wrong or could not be validated.
Is this good news?
For taxpayers, yes. Many businesses win a refund on appeal after years and then hear that no interest is due. This order backs the view that the clock for interest starts at the original application. It also fits with several High Court decisions.
But keep these cautions in mind:
- It is one tribunal order, on one set of facts. The department could challenge it, and other benches or courts may be asked the same question.
- Your application must be complete. The interest depends on the original application being complete in all respects, with the prescribed documents.
- You usually have to ask for it. In this case the taxpayer asked for the interest in its consequential applications and then had to appeal when it was refused.
- The rate here is 6%. The 9% rate applies only if the department is also late after the consequential application.
What you can do
- Note the date of the original refund application (the date your ARN was generated), because that is when the clock starts.
- Make sure the original application is complete, with all the documents the rules require.
- If your claim is rejected, challenge it in time and keep your appeal papers safe.
- After winning, file the consequential application in the right category on the portal, and say clearly that you claim interest from the original application date.
- If interest is refused, ask for a reasoned order so that you can appeal.
- Compare the interest order with Rule 94 to be sure the periods and rate are right.
How Brightfin can help
If you have a refund that was rejected, delayed or paid without interest, we can review your dates and papers and tell you where you stand. See our GST advisory and GST return filing services, or message us on WhatsApp.
Sources
- GST Appellate Tribunal, Andhra Pradesh State Bench, Vijayawada: common order dated 11 November 2026 in Appeal No. APL/1/VJY/2026 and connected appeals, as available in the TaxByKK library
- TaxByKK library, “Section 54 to 58” chapter: section 56 of the CGST Act and Rule 94 of the CGST Rules
- Section 54 and Rules 89 and 93 of the CGST Rules, and CBIC Circular No. 111/30/2019-GST dated 3 October 2019, as set out in the tribunal order
This article is for general information only and is not legal or tax advice. It summarises a tribunal order, which is decided on its own facts and may be challenged or treated differently elsewhere. Please speak to a professional before you act.
